| Class of 2010 |
| Forrest Mason (Hargrave Academy) |
| Mac Stephen (Georgetown) |
| John Bukasa (Frostburg) |
| Dylan Clahar (Frostburg) |
| Sam Lavala (Randolph Macon) |
| Deon Walker (Albright) |
| |
| Class of 2009 |
| Casey Briggs (McDaniel) |
| Danzel Ferguson (Frostburg) |
| Josh Jackson (Frostburg) |
| Aaron Gruber (Frostburg) |
| Gilbert Kim (Bridgewater) |
| Tyler Martin (McDaniel) |
| John Matthew Sienkowski (Susquehanna/Frostburg) |
| |
| Class of 2008 |
| Vinnie Ahearn (Salisbury) |
| Rusty Collins (Frostburg) |
| Alex Cornish (Columbia) |
| Kevin Fisher (Williamson) |
| Jake Guillen (Albright) |
| |
| Class of 2007 |
| David Canada (Shepherd) |
| Quentin Ferguson (Delaware State) |
| Salahuddin Gadson (Delaware State) |
| Pride Rivers (Salisbury) |
| Thomas Threadgill (Delaware State) |
| Anthony Walker (Albany State) |
| Damien Wallace (Frostburg/Salisbury) |
| Lindsey Thomas (Frostburg) "Sports Medicine" |
| Chris Thompson (Fairmont State) |
| |
| Class of 2006 |
| Sean Clement (Frederick Outlaws Semi Pro) |
| Patrick Desmond (McDaniel) |
| Jonathan Figueroa (Fairliegh Dickenson) |
| Geoff Fry (Shepherd) |
| Salahuddin Gadson (Delaware State) |
| Gerald Price (Youngstown State/Shepherd) |
| |
| Class of 2005 |
| Cory Briggs (McDaniel) |
| Micky Davis (Frederick Outlaws Semi Pro) |
| Bruce Dorsey (Shepherd) |
| Andrew Goodwin (Frederick Outlaws Semi Pro) |
| Brian Lanning (William & Mary) |
| Peter Malamet (Duquesne) |
| Tommy Prazenica (McDaniel) |
| Ryan Sheahin (McDaniel) |
| Dale Stephens (Shenandoah) |
| TJ Taylor (Shepherd) |
| Ryan Boettner (West Virginia) "Football Video Department" |
| Billy Gross (West Virginia)(Baltimore Orioles) |
| |
| Class of 2004 |
| Tom Healand (Salisbury) |
| Dallas Pryor (Shenandoah) |
| |
| Class of 2003 |
| Brent Hultslander (Bridgewater) |
| Brad Lawrence (Juniata) |
| Chris Malamet (WVU) |
| Chad Steiner (Juniata) |
| |
| Class of 2002 |
| Pat Cadden (Kings College) |
| Kyle Pittman (Shenandoah) |
| Troy Ward (Clemson/Towson) |
| Jerrod Brown (Frederick Outlaws Semi-Pro) |
| |
| Class of 2001 |
| Kent Bryant (St. Francis)(Frederick Outlaws Semi Pro) |
| Mike Harrison (St. Francis) |
| Akil Patterson (Maryland/California University of Pennsylvania) (AFL-Billings Outlaws) (Frederick Outlaws Semi Pro) |
| Vikas Gowda (North Carolina) (2004 Olympian, India) "Track & Field" |
| |
| Class of 2000 |
| Issac Soloman (Frederick Outlaws Semi Pro) |
| Jermaine Williams (Montgomery College)(Frederick Outlaws Semi Pro) |
| |
| Class of 1999 |
| Brandon Brewbaker (Montgomery College) |
| Ricky Calloway (Montgomery College) (Frederick Outlaws Semi Pro) |
| Pat McGovern (UConn) |
| |
| Class of 1998 |
| Marcus Boyd (Shepherd) (Frederick Outlaws Semi-Pro) |
| Terrence Foreman (Frederick Outlaws Semi Pro) |
| Scott McGregor (Salisbury) |
| Ryan Pinckney (Penn State) |
| Jeff Brabitz (Shepherd/Salisbury) |
| |
| Class of 1997 |
| Alton McCallum (Army) |
| |
| Class of 1996 |
| Andre Daniels (Potomac State) |
| |
| Class of 1992 |
| Mike Kelly (Virginia) |
| Greg Stup (Shepherd) |
| |
| Class of 1991 |
| Bobby Ambush (Montgomery College) |
| |
| Class of 1990 |
| Pat Mooney (Carnegie Mellon) |
| |
| Class of 1989 |
| Scott Clark (Youngstown State) |
| Darren Eichelberger (Frostburg) |
| Brian Gilbert (Shippensburg) |
| Alex Mooney (Dartmouth) |
| Fred Ridgway (Dickinson College) |
| |
| Class of 1988 |
| Terry Leishman (Waynesburg) |
| Greg Wells (Frostburg) |
| |
| Class of 1987 |
| Chuck O'Brien (Clemson) (NFL-San Diego Chargers) |
| William Henry (Shippensburg) |
| Vince Mooney (Yale) |
| Ed Jean (James Madison) |
| |
| Class of 1985 |
| Lee Sornson (Army) |
| Jeff Whiten (Bridgewater) |
| |
| Class of 1982 |
| Tim Brown (Fairmont State) |
| John Icard (Widener) |
| |
| Class of 1981 |
| Steve Stup (Virginia Tech) |
| |
| Class of 1980 |
| Bill Stup (Towson) |
| |
| Class of 1978 |
| Keith Lee (Virginia) (NFL-New England Patriots, Dallas Cowboys) |
| Minton Rose (John Hopkins) |
| Scott Baggett (Fairmont State) |
| |
|
Class of 1977
|
|
Mike Hauk (Salisbury)
|
|
Bert Hill (Salisbury)
|
|
|
|
Class of 1976
|
| Kelvin Anderson (Virginia) |
| |
| Class of 1975 |
| Barry Stranton (Cheney State) |
| Leroy Ambush (Cheney State) |
| |
| Class of 1974 |
| Mike Hahn (Elon) |
| Mike Randolph (Frostburg) |
| Dwayne Danner (Morgan State) |
| Tony Church (Yale) |
| John “Buttons” Lee (Fairmont State) |
| |
| Class of 1973 |
| Mike Daye (Shepherd) |
| Dave Jackson (Shepherd) |
| Mike Sherman (Brown University) |
| Mike Jackson (Shepherd) |
| |
| Class of 1972 |
| Charlie Davis (Bowie State) |
| |
| Class of 1969 |
| Chuck Foreman (Miami,Fl) (NFL-Minnesota Vikings,New England Patriots) |
| Bill Craven (Harvard) (NFL-Cleveland Browns) (WFL-Philadelphia Bells) |
| Ronnie Proctor (Maryland) |
| |
| Class of 1968 |
| Jeff Freland (Morgan State) |
| |
| Class of 1966 |
| Francis Foreman (Cinncinati) |
| |
| Class of 1965 |
| Blaine Smith (Western State) |
| Jack Hart (Western Maryland) |
| Pete Markey (Western Maryland) |
| |
| Class of 1964 |
| David Boyd (Bridgewater) |
| |
| Class of 1962 |
| Guy Stull (Bridgewater) |
| |
| Class of 1960 |
| Dave Markoe (Hartnell Junior College, Ca\Maryland) |
| |
| Class of 1953 |
| Lou Fisher (Staunton Military Academy) |
| |
| Class of 1952 |
| Fred Burgee (Western Maryland) |
| |
| Class of 1951 |
| Dick Shipley (Maryland) |
| |
| Class of 1950 |
| Dick Burgee (Maryland) |
| |
| Class of 1946 |
| Tommy Eichelberger (Frederick VFW Semi Pro) |
| |
| Class of 1916 |
| Robert Lebherz (Mount Saint Mary's) |
| Charles Houck (Gettysburg) |
