2010
1st Team - Chris Fish (TE/P), Trevor St. Clair (WR), Nick Moore (OG), Mike Moran (DT), BJ Godfrey (LB), Earl Parks (DB),Joey Painter (FS), Mitch Ryder (PK)

2nd Team - Ken Stay (QB), Zach Blocker (RB), Kevin Tyler (C), Kyle Babbie (DE), Dan Marbut (DE)

Honorable Mentions - Mike Archer, Adam Frennier, Jordon Keleher, Ray Nelson, Nick Norris, Dan O'Meara, Josh Painter, Elija Parks, Shane Racette, Harry Rascoe, Brandon St. John and Dave Staley.

2009
1st Team - Kyle Babbie (DE), Zach Blocker (PR), John Dubuc (OG), Chris Fish (TE & P), Kevin Gibson (DE), BJ Godfrey (LB), Brandon Keleher (RB), Mitch Ryder (PK)
2nd Team - Zach Blocker (RB), Nick Moore (OT), Matt St. Clair (S), Brandon St. John (DB), Mike Thwaits (NT), Jeff Way (DT)
Honorable Mention - Joe Beshon, Donny Coolidge, Dustin Fredericks, Adam Frennier, Kelly Gordon, Jordon Keleher, Jamil McCray, Ray Nelson, Nick Norris, Elija Parks, Joey Painter, and Ken Stay.

2008
EFL “Iron Man” - Heath Geiser
1st Team - BJ Godfrey (LB), Kyle Nolan (FB), Ryon Sorrell (OG), Trevor St. Clair (TE),
Brandon St. John, (DB)
2nd Team - Kyle Babbie (DE), Adam Frennier (LB), Jon Garrow (OT), Brandon Keleher (RB), Ray Nelson (OG)
Honorable Mention - Jordon Keleher, Craig Lamoy, Nick Moore, Kellen Nolan, Josh Pray, Ken Ruwett, Matt St. Clair, Mike Thwaits

2007
EFL “Iron Man” - Heath Geiser
1st Team - Kyle Babbie (DE), BJ Godfrey (LB), Nick Moore (OC), Kyle Nolan (FB), Matt St. Clair (WR), Brandon St. John, (DB), Mike Thwaits (DT)
2nd Team - Brandon Keleher (RB), Craig Lamoy (OT), Ryon Sorrell (OG), Nick Weaver (DT)
Honorable Mention - Kellen Nolan, Trevor St. Clair

2006
All-North - Shane Cheeseman (LB), Heath Geiser (KR), Brandon Keleher (RB), Mike Lawyer (LB), Nick Moore (OG), Earl Parks (DB), Trevor St. Clair (TE), Don Tambini (DT), Gus Terry (P)

2005
1st Team - Nick Moore (OG), Gus Terry (P)
2nd Team - Shane Cheeseman (LB), Kellen Nolan (DB), Matt St. Clair (DB), Jeff Way (DT)

2004
Defensive Rookie of the Year - Dan Trudeau
1st Team - Mike Archer (OT), Duane Godfrey (FB), Mike Lawyer (LB), Dave Staley (DT)
2nd Team - Eric Bjornstad (LB), Ed Castine (QB), Nick Damiani (DB)

2003
Offensive Rookie of the Year - Ed Castine
Coach of the Year - Ed MacCallister
1st Team - Eric Bjornstad (LB), Mark Burrell (TE), Keith Bushey (OT), Ed Castine (QB), Cory Lawyer (RB), Mike Lawyer (LB), Kellen Nolan (DB), Earl Parks (DB), Bob Smith (DT), Don Tambini (NT), Jeff Way (DT), Jake Wilson (DE)
2nd Team - Mike Archer (OT), Joe Bushey (OC), Nick Damiani (DB), Heath Geiser (WR), Duane Godfrey (RB), Lan Lamonde (OG), Jake Maye (FB), Ian Smart (DE), Jim Tyler (DB)

2002
None Reported

2001
None Reported

2000
Offensive Rookie of the Year - Mark Golden
Defensive Player of the Year - Ken Hackett
1st Team - Ken Hackett (DE), Steve St. Clair (TE/DB), Dave Staley (DT), Jeff Way (DT), Jake Wilson (DE)
2nd Team - Craig Duprey (DB), Mark Golden (QB), Corey Lawyer (RB), Jamie Lozier (DB), Tim Viens (P)

1999
1st Team - Brian Chreitzberg (WR), Dave Staley (DE)
2nd Team - Jamie Lozier (DB), Dan Marbut (RB)

1998
Offensive Rookie of the Year - Craig Duprey
Iron Man of the Year - Jamie Lozier
1st Team - Vince Kuziomko (DT)
2nd Team - Jamie Lozier (DB)
Honorable Mention - Allen (TE), Chartrand (OC), Duprey (QB), Gale (LB), Marbut (DB), Staley (OT), Valliers (OG)

1997
1st Team - Vince Kuziomko (DT), Dave Ransom (RB)
2nd Team - Glenn Arnold (DB/KR)

1996
None Reported

1995
Offensive Player of the Year - Wade Johnson
EFL Iron Man - Mike Skaggs
1st Team - Madison Johnson (OC), Wade Johnson (RB), Brian Kemp (P), Shannon Manor (LB), Mike Skaggs (DB)
2nd Team - Matt Inhelder (OG), Steve Lalonde (WR), Brian Passino (DE), Lon Rosen (QB), Shawn Silakowski (OT)
Honorable Mention - Craig Allison, Deryl Lane, Chris Lorden, Jamie Lozier, Keith Kuziomko, Dave Staley, Keith Tedford, Jake Wilson
1994
1st Team - Troy Canada (KR), Brian Kemp (P), Al Smith (DE)
2nd Team - Terral Beauford (RB), Randy Brown (QB), Jerry Defayette (DT), Fred Edquid (DB), Frank Kirby (DB), Shannon Manor (LB), Mike Martin (DT), Brian Passino (DE)
1993
Rookie of the Year - Eric Brumskill
1st Team - Eric Brumskill (RB), Brian Kemp (PK), LaBreece Perry (DB), Al Smith (DE)
2nd Team - Troy Canada (WR), Brian Kemp (P), Jay Passalaqua (LB), Shannon Manor (LB), Keith Tedford (OC)
Honorable Mention - Eric Barry, Brian Passino
1992
Rookie of the Year - Bobby Adams
1st Team - None
2nd Team - Keith Tedford (OC), Robin Vaughn (DB)
Honorable Mention - Bobby Adams, Shannon Manor, Jay Passalaqua, Jay Perras, Chris Rowell, Tim Senecal, Al Smith, Tom Wilder

1991
1st Team - Roy Ebersole (WR), Shannon Manor (DE), Keith Tedford (OT), Tom Wilder (DB), James Ziglor (RB)
2nd Team - Al Brinson (OC), Daryl Brown (KR), Tim Senecal (DT), Ed Tharnisch (P)
Honorable Mention - Reggie Alexander, Blaine Applegate, Jerry Defayette, Steve Docteur, Fred Edquid George Facteau, Brian Foster, Mike Ida, Sam Kelly, Todd Laurin, Charlie McCormick, Jerome McCray, Chris Rowell, Paul Vallieres, Robin Vaughn