2017: Blaine Rutledge (Minnetonka Millers)

2016: Joe Shallenberger (Minnetonka Millers)

2015: Donny Erdall (Minnetonka Millers)

2014: Josh Kubitschek (St. Paul Capitals)

2013: Kris Edwards (St. Paul Shamrocks)

2012: Joe Shallenberger & Nate Melek (Minnetonka Millers)

2011: Zack Goodwin (Stockmen's Irish)

2010: Brendan Furrow (Minnetonka Millers)

2009: Joe Shallenberger (Minnetonka Millers)

2008: Gabe Eikum & Dave Lindstrom (St. Louis Park)

2007: Corey Eckoff & Joe Abellera (Minnetonka Millers)

2006: Tony Richards (Minnetonka Millers)

2005: Ben Fleetham (Wesley Homes)

2004: Joe Shallenberger (Minnetonka Millers)

2003: Tony Richards (Minnetonka Millers)

2002: Matt Paulsen (St. Louis Park)

2001: Matt Parrington (Minnetonka Millers)

2000: Glynn Building's entire team (Glynn Building)

1999: Bryan Krull (Minnetonka Millers)

1998: Dave Holland (St. Louis Park)

1997: Bryan Krull (Minnetonka Millers)

1996: Matt Farley (Highland Park)

1995: Dave Lance (Rosetown)

1994: Bill Zeller (Minneapolis Angels)

1993: Steve Berryhill (Highland Park)

1992: No selection

1991: Jim Meyer (Minneapolis Angels)

1990: Mark Crandall (Conquest Rooster)

1989: Randy Moselle (Columbia Heights)

1988: Steve Sagedahl (J. Botten)

1987: No Selection

1986: Randy Moselle (Columbia Heights)