Most Valuable Wrestler
2001- Jeremy Hamilton
2002- Jason Carroll
2003- Nick Newton
2004- Matt Nelson
2005- Matt Miller
2006- Matt Miller
2007- Tristan Bourque
2008- Alex Lanier
2009- Alex Lanier and Elliot Bourne
2010- Chris O'Connor and Brian Kennedy
2011- Ryan Cross
2012- Travis Scott
2013- Matt Carroll

Zach Wilson Team Captain Award
2003- Bryan Reed
2004- Heath Westray
2005- Alex Haney and Jeremy Walker
2006- Brent Sawyer and Evan Martin
2008- John Hill
2009- Zach Wilson
2010- Chris Ray and Dylan Cross
2011- Ryan Cross
2012- Will Robinson
2013- Austin Thornton

Most Improved
2003- Brandon Kimmons
2004- Casey Sheets
2005- Brian Bourque
2006- Matt Cameron
2007- Dillon Thomas and Josh Massey
2008- Chris O'Connor and Ryan Carroll
2009- Chris Ray
2010- Ryan Carroll and Will Robinson
2011- Evan Miller
2012- Evan Miller
2013- Jake Nash and Drew Kent

Most Aggressive
2003- Zak Miller
2004- Matt Miller
2005- Matt Miller
2006- Josh Pledger
2007- Ryan Berry
2008- Tristan Bourque
2009- Tristan Bourque
2010- Ryan Cross
2011- Steve Hill
2012- Mitchell Abreu
2013- Ara Johnson 

Unsung Hero
2003- Cole McDaniel
2004- Matt Waldron
2005- Chad Tillery
2006- Kyle McDaniel
2007- John Hill
2008- Zach Wilson
2009- Dylan Cross and Jesse McWhorter
2010- Zach Coker
2011- John Brown and Will Robinson
2012- John Brown
2013- Luke Slaton

Potentially Dangerous
2006- Cole Westray
2007- Chris O'Connor and Brian Kennedy
2008- Ryan Cross
2009- Will Robinson
2010- Matt Carroll
2011- Luke Slaton
2012- Ara Johnson
2013- Tanner Buggs

Rookie of the Year
2003- Matt Miller and Matt Waldron
2004- Tanner Thomas and Kyle McDaniel
2005- Cy Allen
2006- Tristan Bourque
2007- Graham Simmons
2008- Michael Abreu
2009- John Michael Brown
2010- Mitchell Abreu
2011- Shane Cross
2012- John Fulkerson and Stevie Anthony
2013- Jose Martinez

Coaches Award
2003- Brian Adams and John Wilson
2004- Alex Haney
2005- Casey Sheets and Matt Nelson
2006- Tyler Fitzgerald and Scott Bailey
2007- Ray Nosari and Brent Eichler
2008- Jeff Briend, James Knight, and Kevin Sapp
2009- Ryan Blocker, Joe Haberkam, Alex LaSalle
2010- John Michael Brown
2011- Dillon Martin and Jose Santana
2012- Drew Fulkerson, Joseph Burns, Brandon Gwaltney and Jacob Porter
2013- Preston Ernst and Patrick Englishby

Manager Awards
2004- Kim Butler and Christina Dixon
2007- Hannah Splawn
2008- Stephanie Jones and Tina Nosari
2010- Kelsey Maher and Quinn Johnson
2012- Kelsey Papineau
2013- Maria Belanger and Candace Bourque