(Since 2009)

Highest Scoring Doubleheader
5/15/16 - Fred. Presbyterian vs. FCOB - 118 runs
4/17/11 - Fred. Presbyterian vs. St. Timothy's Red - 114 runs
6/6/10 - New Beginning vs. Middletown CRUCC - 114 runs

Highest Scoring Game
4/17/11 - Fred. Presbyterian 28 vs. St. Timothy's Red 43 - 71 runs
5/15/16 - FCOC 33 vs. Fred. Presbyterian 31 - 64 runs
7/31/11 - St. Peter's vs. St. Ignatius - 64 runs

Lowest Scoring Doubleheader
7/26/09 - St. Katharine's vs. Middletown UM - 13 runs
5/22/11 - Seventh Day vs. St. Peter's - 18 runs

Lowest Scoring Game
4/24/16 - St. Peter's 2 vs. St. Katharine's 1 - 3 runs
5/22/11 - Seventh Day vs. St. Peter's - 7 runs

Longest Regular Season Win Streak
2011/12 - Middletown CRUCC - 32 games (2011 & 2012 seasons)
2009 - St. John's - 17 games (first 17 games of the season)
2014 - Middletown UMC - 16 games (final 16 games of the season)