Paepke, Taylor (Sussex Cardinals)
Paffhausen, Nick (Muskego Impact)
Pagal, Zach (North Shore Knights)
*Paikowski, Brandon (Port Washington Lakers)
*Paikowski, Nathan (Port Washington Lakers)
Palafito, Josh (Thiensville-Mequon Twins)
*Panagos, Peter (Rome Raiders)
*Pangborm, Mike (Hartland Oilers)
*Papke, Skyler (Delavan Blackhawks)
*Parent, Derek (Hartland Oilers)
Parrent, Matt (West Bend 7UP)
*Partier, Ben (New Berlin Lakers)
Paszek, Joran (North Prairie Dawgs)
*Paul, Matt (Delavan Blackhawks)
*Paulauskas, Andrew (Kenosha Merchants)
*Pauly, Tim (West Bend Benders)
Paulson, Tyler (Rome Raiders)
*Paun, Joey (Monches Irish)
*Pautz, Joshua (Rome Raiders)
Peake, Derek (Pewaukee Muskies)
Pearson, Andrew (Burlington Barons)
*Pearson, Eric (Brookfield Blue Sox)
*Pease, Jim (Brookfield Blue Sox)
Pederson, Lance (Rome Raiders)
*Pederson, Leroy (Pewaukee Muskies)
*Pederson, Talor (East Troy Express)
*Peiffer, Coleman (Waukesha Firebirds)
Peil, Adrian (East Troy Express)
Peltz, David (North Shore Knights)
*Pena, Mike (Racine Kiwanis)
Pennington, Tommy (Racine Kiwanis)
Perez, Eric (Saukville Saints)
Perez, Jake (West Bend 7UP)
*Perez, Mario (Kenosha Merchants)
*Perleberg, Chris (Ixonia Snappers)
Perleberg, Kraig (Cedarburg Mercs)
Perleberg, Marcus (Wales/Waukesha Royals)
*Perleberg, Mike (Ixonia Snappers)
*Perlewitz, Greg (Thiensville-Mequon Twins)
*Perry, Brandon (Genoa City Red Dogs)
*Perscayk, John (Franklin Snappers)
*Persick, Matt (Oconomowoc Titans)
Pestras, Jarek (Hartland Oilers)
*Peters, Jason (Delavan Blackhawks)
*Peters, Jeff (New Berlin Lakers)
*Peterson, Brett (Burlington Barons)
Peterson, Cody (Burlington Barons)
*Peterson, Eric (Monches Irish)
*Peterson, Jay (Delavan Blackhawks)
*Peterson, Nolan (New Berlin Lakers)
Petrosky, Kyle (Merton Amvets)
*Petti, Mike (Kenosha Merchants)
*Pettis, A.J. (Racine Erickson)
*Pettis, Ron (Racine Erickson)
*Pfeffer, Jacob (Howards Grove Riverdogs)
Pfeiffer, John (Genessee Rebels)
*Pickett, Andy (Ixonia Snappers)
*Piedot, Rob (Delavan Blackhawks)
*Piedot, Ryan (West Bend 7UP)
Piel, Taylor (Cedarburg Mercs)
*Piemeisl, Ryan (Racine Erickson)
*Pierce, Mike (Racine Kiwanis)
*Pierce, Mikole (Racine Kiwanis)
Pierce, Nick (Oconomowoc Titans)
*Piering, Nathan (Waukesha Firebirds)
Pierron, MIke (Saukville Saints)
Pierson, Justin (Merton Amvets)
*Pierson, Chris (Oconomowoc Titans)
*Pieters, Joe (Burlington Barons)
Pignotti, Max (North Shore Knights)
*Pindyck, Blake (Racine Kiwanis)
*Pinnt, Ben (Ixonia Snappers)
Pinsoneault, KC (Brookfield Bulldogs)
*Pinzer, Ben (Grafton Express)
*Pitrof, Jeff (Menomonee Falls Lakers)
*Pitsch, Conrad (Monches Irish)
*Plese, Luke (Sussex Cardinals)
*Pluess, Tom (East Troy Express)
*Poedtke, Lance (Kenosha Merchants)
Poellinger, Colten (Thiensville-Mequon Twins)
*Poelmann, Nathan (Racine Kiwanis)
Poeske, Max (Menomonee Falls Lakers)
*Pogodzinski, Justin (Muskego Impact)
*Polifka, Craig (Howards Grove Riverdogs)
*Poniewaz, Ken (Brookfield Blue Sox)
*Porcaro, Andrew (Burlington Barons)
*Porcaro, Anthony (Burlington Barons)
Porcaro, Mike (Burlington Barons)
*Porter, C.J. (Wales Royals)
Postulek, Bill (Brookfield Blue Sox)
*Poth, Dane (Howards Grove Riverdogs)
Potratz, Tom (Thiensville-Mequon Twins)
*Poulson, Tim (North Prairie Dawgs)
*Pourier, Justin (Howards Grove Riverdogs)
*Pourier, Randy (Howards Grove Riverdogs)
*Povlick, Ryan (New Berlin Lakers)
*Powers, Brad (North Shore Knights)
Preston, Will (Butler Bombers)
Prellwitz, Kiley (Port Washington Lakers)
Price, Chris (Merton Amvets)
Prideaux, Zach (Thiensville-Mequon Twins)
*Procinski, Brian (Muskego Impact)
Proehl, Robby (Rome Raiders)
*Prokryfke, Ken (Genoa City Red Dogs)
Pronschinski, Alex (North Prairie Dawgs)
*Proud, Brett (Oconomowoc Five-O's)
*Proud, Nate (Wales Royals)
Pruefer, Max (Grafton Express)
Pruefer, Mickey (Grafton Express)
Pruefer, Mike (Grafton Express)
Pruett, Tanner (Grafton Express)
*Pruett, Turner (Grafton Express)
Prusinski, Brian (Muskego Impact)
*Prust, Derrick (North Lake Lakers)
*Pryal, Curt (New Berlin Lakers)
*Pucely, Zachary (Thiensville-Mequon Twins)
*Pucher, Andy (Kenosha Merchants)
*Pulkowski, Bob (Menomonee Falls Lakers)
*Purdue, Matt (Delavan Blackhawks)
*Pusateri, Kyle (Kenosha Merchants)
*Putnam, Dan (New Berlin Lakers)
Putterman, Andrew (North Shore Knights)
Putterman, CJ (North Shore Knights)