| Season |
Year |
ERA |
| Chad Livingston-Cove Run Free Methodist |
2011 |
2.33 |
| Bill Layhue-Cove Run Free Methodist |
2020 |
2.39 |
| Bill Layhue, Cove Run Free Methodist |
2023 |
2.41 |
| Bill Layhue-Carmichaels Free Methodist (Mosaic) |
2010 |
2.69 |
| Rich Kolesar, EOT Ministries |
2024 |
2.79 |
| Rich Kolesar, EOT Ministries |
2025 |
2.96 |
| Chuck Durso-McClellandtown FM (Mosaic) |
2004 |
3.11 |
| Merle Crossland-Cove Run Free Methodist |
2007 |
3.23 |
| Pat Livingston-Cove Run Free Methodist |
2022 |
3.32 |
| Merle Crossland-Cove Run Free Methodist |
2006 |
3.39 |
| Pat Livingston, Cove Run Free Methodist |
2024 |
3.39 |
| Rich Kolesar, EOT Ministries |
2023 |
3.92 |
| Tim Fung-Carmichaels Free Methodist (Mosaic) |
2010 |
3.95 |
| Bill Layhue, Jr., Cove Run Free Methodist |
2025 |
3.95 |
| Rich Kolesar-EOT Ministries |
2022 |
4.23 |
| Rich Kolesar, EOT Ministries |
2021 |
4.30 |
| Randy Thomas-Cherry Tree Alliance (EOT) |
2011 |
4.36 |
| Steve Hart-Cove Run Free Methodist |
2005 |
4.37 |
| Jed Friend-First Baptist Church of Fairchance |
2025 |
4.50 |
| Keith Wadsworth, Sr.-1st Bapt. Church, Fairchance |
2024 |
4.60 |
| Rich Kolesar-EOT Ministries |
2017 |
4.79 |
| Chad Livingston-Cove Run Free Methodist |
2020 |
4.90 |
| Jake Provance, 1st Christian Church, New Salem |
2025 |
5.02 |
| Bill Layhue, Jr., Cove Run Free Methodist |
2024 |
5.19 |
| Kevin Wingrove-Mountainview Christian |
2010 |
5.21 |
| Jason Myers-Mosaic Ministries |
2017 |
5.31 |
| Jason Myers-Mosaic Ministries |
2014 |
5.33 |
| Travis Wingrove-Mountainview Christian |
2012 |
5.48 |
| Keith Wadsworth, Sr., Upon this Rock |
2021 |
5.58 |
| Chad Livingston, Cove Run Free Methodist |
2024 |
5.68 |
| Jason Myers, Mosaic Ministries |
2021 |
5.76 |
| Randy Fisher, Mosaic Ministries |
2021 |
5.76 |
| Pat Livingston, Cove Run Free Methodist |
2025 |
5.81 |
| Colby Simmons, Mountain Fellowship Center |
2024 |
5.88 |
| Rich Kolesar-EOT Ministries |
2016 |
5.91 |
