| Season |
Year |
Batting Ave. |
| "Squirrel" Livingston, Cove Run FM |
2023 |
.838 |
| Paul Eckert-Mt. Moriah Baptist |
2005 |
.833 |
| Paul Eckert-Mt. Moriah Baptist |
2006 |
.801 |
| Jeff Meixell-Abundant Life |
2008 |
.788 |
| Chad Livingston, Cove Run FM |
2023 |
.788 |
| Brian Gaudiano-Cherry Tree Alliance (EOT) |
2011 |
.773 |
| Ryan Gondek-Mosaic Ministries |
2014 |
.756 |
| George Hayes-Mosaic Ministries |
2017 |
.755 |
| Jeff Meixell-Pechin's Chapel Youth |
2007 |
.750 |
| Jeff Meixell-Fairdale Free Methodist (Mosaic) |
2009 |
.750 |
| Cole Novotney, EOT Ministries |
2023 |
.750 |
| Rich Kolesar-EOT Ministries |
2014 |
.745 |
| Eric Russman-Carmichaels Free Methodist (Mosaic) |
2012 |
.740 |
| Keith Myers-EOT Ministries |
2015 |
.736 |
| Matt Myers-EOT Ministries |
2016 |
.735 |
| Keith Myers-EOT Ministries |
2017 |
.735 |
| Tim Fung-Carmichaels Free Methodist (Mosaic) |
2011 |
.733 |
| Eric Russman-Mosaic Ministries |
2020 |
.733 |
| TJ Rose-Mosaic Ministries |
2017 |
.731 |
| Ray Shaffer-Cove Run Free Methodist |
2011 |
.727 |
| Don Miller-Adelphoi |
2012 |
.727 |
| Eric Russman-Mosaic Ministries |
2014 |
.727 |
| Josh Hertlein-Fairchance 1st Baptist |
2020 |
.724 |
| Rich Kolesar-EOT Ministries |
2017 |
.722 |
| Ty Schaefer-EOT Ministries |
2017 |
.722 |
| Jarrett Bond-Adelphoi |
2012 |
.714 |
| Dom Peroni, Cove Run FM |
2023 |
.714 |
| Don Miller-Faith Assembly of God |
2011 |
.710 |
| Dom Peroni-Cove Run Free Methodist |
2022 |
.710 |
| Josh Landman-Mountainview Christian |
2010 |
.707 |
| Jake Provance-Fairchance 1st Baptist |
2020 |
.707 |
| Tyler Hensley-Farmington Bethel |
2013 |
.706 |
| Jimmy Pierce, Cove Run FM |
2023 |
.704 |
| Alan Witt-EOT Ministries |
2014 |
.700 |
| Jeremy Baukol, Cove Run FM |
2023 |
.700 |
