1998- Rodney Methodist (7-1)
1999- Nazarene Church* (8-0)
2000- First Baptist (8-0)
2001- Nazarene Church* (7-2)
2002- First Baptist/Living Water Church* (7-1)
2003- Rodney Methodist/First Baptist (8-1)
2004- Rodney Methodist/First Baptist (7-1)
2005- First Baptist (7-1)
2006- Good News Baptist* (7-1)
2007- Good News Baptist*/First Baptist (7-1)
2008- Good News Baptist* (9-0)
2009- First Church of God (10-0)
2010- Rodney Methodist (10-0)
2011- First Church of God (10-0)
2012- First Church of God/Elizabeth Chapel* (9-1)
2013- Rodney Church of Light (12-0)

2014- Rodney Church of Light/River City Fellowship (9-1)

2015- River City Fellowship/First Church of God (8-1)

2016- First Church of God/Rodney Church of Light (7-1)

2017- First Church of God (7-1)

2018- First Church of God (8-0)

2019- First Church of God/River of Life UMC (7-1)

1998- Nazarene Church*
1999- First Baptist
2000- Nazarene Church*
2001- Nazarene Church*
2002- Middleport Church of Christ*
2003- Living Water Church*
2004- First Baptist
2005- Middleport Church of Christ*
2006- Good News Baptist*
2007- Rodney Methodist
2008- Good News Baptist*
2009- Rodney Methodist
2010- Rodney Methodist
2011- First Church of God
2012- First Church of God
2013- Rodney Church of Light

2014- First Church of God

2015- Rodney Church of Light

2016- First Church of God

2017- First Church of God

2018- First Church of God

2019- River City Fellowship

1998- Rodney Methodist (7-1)
1999- Gallipolis Christian (8-0)
2000- Gallipolis Christian (8-0)
2001- Gallipolis Christian (8-1)
2002- Middleport Church of Christ*/First Church of God (6-2)
2003- First Church of God (8-1)
2004- Rodney Methodist (8-0)
2005- Rodney Methodist (8-0)
2006- First Church of God (8-0)
2007- Rodney Methodist (8-0)
2008- First Baptist (9-0)
2009- First Baptist (10-0)
2010- Rodney Methodist (9-1)
2011- Fellowship of Faith (9-1)
2012- First Baptist (9-1)
2013- First Baptist/First Church of God/River City Fellowship (10-2)
2014- River City Fellowship (10-0)

2015- Fellowship of Faith (9-0)

2016- Fellowship of Faith (7-1)

2017- Rodney Church of Light/River City Fellowship (7-1)

2018- River City Fellowship/Fellowship of Faith (7-1)

2019- Fellowship of Faith/Rodney Church of Light (7-1)

1998- Gallipolis Christian
1999- Gallipolis Christian
2000- Faith Baptist*
2001- Gallipolis Christian/Faith Baptist*
2002- First Church of God
2003- First Baptist
2004- First Baptist
2005- First Church of God
2006- Rodney Methodist
2007- First Church of God
2008- Rodney Methodist
2009- Rodney Methodist
2010- Rodney Methodist
2011- Rodney Methodist
2012- First Baptist
2013- River City Fellowship

2014- Fellowship of Faith

2015- Fellowship of Faith

2016- Fellowship of Faith

2017- River City Fellowship

2018- River City Fellowship

2019-Fellowship of Faith

(Rodney Methodist is now Rodney Church of Light)

* No longer a member of the GCCSL