1993 Craig Witte - FS - Buffaloes
1994 James Scott - DL - Hurricanes
1995 Matt Stephen - MLB - Seminoles
1996 Shawn Staton - DL - Thunder
1998 Don Acker - SS - Bottleshop
1999 Chay Stout - DB - Martini's
         Mike Ripperger - DL - Bottleshop
2000 Paul Stanley - DB - Cars Inc.
2001 Paul Stanley - DB - Cars Inc.
         Chad Davis - DB - Faber Construction
2002 Ricardo Tipton - DB - Ohio Players
2003 Pat Brown - DB - United
2004 Ricardo Tipton - DB - Ohio Players
2005 David Hughes - LB - Wolfpack
         Pat Brown - DB - Construction Specialists
2006 Jedaciah Moore - DB - Wolfpack
2007 Pat Brown - DB - United
2008 Kyle Hine - DL - Ohio Players
2009 Steve Clark - DB - Saver Systems
2010 Jon York - LB - Wolfpack
2011 Curtis "C-Mac" McDonald - DL - Jets
2012 Trey Rogers - LB - Cowboys
2013 Ben Chance - LB - Misfits
2014 (S) Phil Tyler - DB - Seahawks
2014 (F) Trey Rogers - LB - 49ers
2015 (S) Trey Rogers - LB - Outla
               Jarvis Hogg - LB - Carryout Boyz
2015 (F) Jarvis Hogg - LB - Carryout Boyz
2016 (S) Jarvis Hogg - LB - Carryout Boyz
2016 (F) Curtis "C-Mac" McDonald - DL - Outlaws
2017 (S) Travon "Captain" Cordova - DB - Falcons
2017 (F) Curtis McDonald - DL - Team USA
2018 (S) Isaiah Rader - DB - Falcons
2018 (F) Trey Rogers - LB - Savages / COB
2019 (S) Kain Grose - LB - COB
2019 (F) Mathew Hartman - DL - Falcons
2020 (S) Season cancelled due to COVID 19
2020 (F) Jarvis Hogg - LB -  COB
2021 (S) Cam Rader - DB - Falcons
2021 (F) Trey Rogers - LB -Falcons
2022 (S) Trey Rogers - LB - Falcons
2022 (F) Trey Rogers - LB - Falcons
2023 (S) Trey Rogers - LB - Falcons
               Kristian "K-Rod" Rodriguez - LB - Squaad