2018

Sami Buettell - Cederville University

Rylee Tomsic - Heidelberg University

2016

Melissa Jacobsen - Cleveland State

Mollie Paulick - Eastern Kentucky University

Kianah Towe - University of Missouri-St. Louis

Mackenzie Watson - University of Northwestern Ohio

2015

Jesse Dmochowski - Northern Kentucky University

Chevonne Hayslett - Capital University

Ciara Incorvati - Bellarmine University

Hannah Trent - Ursuline

Morgan Wells - Mount Vernon

2014

Alli Castle - Ohio Northern

Morgan Daniels - Tiffin University

Maddi Ehrenborg - Urbana University

Alex Jander - Miami University (Ohio)

Brooke Shad - Capital University

Chelsea Zang - Wittenberg University

2013 

Jamie Ertel - Thomas More College

Laurel Hopf - University of the Cumberlands

Randi Kelsey - Heildelberg University

Alexis Mayle - Wright State University

Chelsea Miller - University of Northwestern Ohio

Rachael Oakley - Wright State University 

Rebekkah Potter - University of Dayton

2012

Caitlyn Calhoun - Valdosta State

Hannah Floyd - Wright State University

Emily Froment - University of Dayton

Jessica Gregg - Bowling Green

Morgan Haer - Urbana University

Jenna King - Tiffin University

Becka Peterson - Wright State University

Katelind Phillips - Cleveland State

Jenny Sharpe - Indiana Wesleyan

Katie Whetstone - Tennessee Tech