2017
Gabe Schimpf - SEMO
Steven Anderson - MacMurray

2014
Gabe Jelley - John A. Logan
Bailey Schimpf - John A. Logan

2012
RJ Kuh - Morthland College

2011
Dylan Arvai - Shawnee College and Lindenwood-Belleville

2010
Tyler Mitchell - Greenville College

2009
Keith Bennett - Lindenwood University

2004
Joe Kretz - Rend Lake College

1999
Scott Clark - Lincoln Trail

1997
Jared Freeman - John A. Logan College and Indiana Tech

1995
Mike Bramlett - John A. Logan College

1993
Page Kirkpatrick - Rend Lake College

1992
Mike Rolla - Southeastern Illinois College and Rend Lake College