2021 - Coach Al Ellis & Yirdaw Rivera          2025 - Brayden O'Boyle & Coach Joe Camarda  
                                                                        

  2025 - Brayden O'Boyle, Commack & Iona
  2024 - CJ Marino, West Islip & Oswego
  2023 - Cristian Escobar - Brentwood & Stony Brook
  2022 - Brandon Miller - Longwood & Sacred Heart University
  2021 - Yirdaw Rivera - Sayville & U.S. Military Academy at West Point
  2020 - Adrian Vides - Brentwood & Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute
  2019 - Nickolas Dittmer - Eastport/South Manor & Florida Southern University
  2018 - Tyler Meotti - Commack & Binghamton University

***