Year Team Age Manager MVP
1986 Klockner 40 Charlie Smith
1987 Newmarket Klockner 40 Charlie Smith
1988 Green CML 40 Bill Green
1989 Scarborough Masters 40 Bill Oliver
1990 Toronto Tough Guys 40 Ron Kimel
1991 Oshawa Klockner 40 Charlie Smith
1992 Green CML 40 Bill Green
1993 Green CML 40 Bill Green
1994 Toronto Tough Guys 40 Ron Kimel
1995 Green CML 40 Bill Green
1996 Shucker’s 40 Bill Green
1997 Tough Guys 40 Ron Kimel
1998 Run & Gun 40 Charlie Smith
1998 Bo Peep 50 Mark Slater
1999 Smith & Fraser 40 Perry Doukas
1999 Masters 50 Bill Oliver
2000 Labatt 40 Dennis Stief
2000 Advil 50 Bob Selkirk
2001 Friars 40 Jeff Horton Calvin Smith
2001 Shucker’s 50 Art Darnbrough Larry Lloyd
2002 Friars 40 Jeff Horton Calvin Smith
2002 Advil 50 Bill Oliver Arvid Stonkus
2003 North York Dukes 40 Phil Porter Jude Kelly
2003 Shuckers 55 Art Darnbrough Al Birkett
2004 TBA 40 Kirk Mark Chris McNeilly
2004 Hounds 55 John O’Connor Tom Truty
2005 North York Dukes 40 Phil Porter Conrad Davis
2005 Hounds 55 Ross May Gus Falcioni
2006 North York Dukes 40 Phil Porter Conrad Davis
2006 Knights 55 Paul Skowron Paul Bilewicz
2007 Green Storm 40 Richard Dean Darren Thomas
2007 Hounds 55 John O'Connor Zito Baccarani
2008 North York Dukes 40 Phil Porter Conrad Davis
2008 Masters 55 Bob Selkirk Eric Heidendahl
2009 Masters 55 Bob Selkirk Perry Doukas
2010 Hounds 55 Basil Mangano Perry Doukas
2011 Masters 55 Bob Selkirk Wies Nycz
2012 The Hardwood Flooring Stores Basil Mangano Chris McNeilly
2013 Masters Chris McNeilly

2014 Knights Francis Moccio

2015 Run & Gun Joe Braunstein & Tony Braunstein (Roger Tustanoff Playoff MVP)

2016 Masters (Jude Kelly Playoff MVP)