| Year | Name | Position | School |
|---|
| 2013 |
Chris Bumstead |
P |
Dickinson College |
| 2013 |
Zach DeVincenzo |
P |
St. Joseph's University |
| 2013 |
Evan Gillespie |
P |
Lamar Community College |
| 2013 |
Cam Hoos |
P |
DeSales University |
| 2013 |
Greg Kocinski |
3B |
Marist College |
| 2013 |
Robert LaRue |
2B |
Kueka College |
| 2013 |
DJ Nozza |
1B |
St. Peter's University |
| 2013 |
Ben Verducci |
SS |
Haverford College |
| 2012 |
Brett Ender |
P |
Seton Hall University |
| 2012 |
Gerry Patrizio |
SS |
Rutgers University, Newark |
| 2012 |
Erik Lanzner |
P |
Penn State University, Berks |
| 2011 |
Jason Kalvin |
P |
The College of New Jersey |
| 2011 |
DJ Ruhlman |
SS |
Seton Hall University |
| 2011 |
Ryan Carmon |
P |
Wagner College / The College of New Jersey |
| 2011 |
Nick Covello |
2B |
Millersville University / Cornerstone University |
| 2010 |
Mike Friel |
SS |
University of Connecticut / Hofstra University |
| 2010 |
Josh Prevost |
P |
Seton Hall University |
| 2010 |
Kyle Wernicki |
OF |
Virginia Tech University |
| 2009 |
Jonathon Prosinski |
P |
Seton Hall University |
| 2008 |
Steve Perone |
1B |
Wesley College |
| 2008 |
Cory Weingart |
OF |
Delaware Valley College |
| 2008 |
Andrew Mahle |
OF |
Denison University |
| 2007 |
Alex Mann |
P |
Sacred Heart University |
| 2007 |
Matt Pizzolato |
OF |
Wesley College |
| 2007 |
Ryan Peterson |
P |
Rowan University |
| 2007 |
John Kane |
C |
Dean College |
| 2006 |
Scott Brady |
OF/INF |
Moravian College |
| 2006 |
Chris Zimmerman |
OF |
McDaniel College |
| 2006 |
James Boyer |
OF |
Lehigh University |
| 2006 |
Dale Hering |
P |
Rutgers University / Wagner College |
| 2005 |
Kevin Weingart |
OF |
Delaware Valley College |
| 2005 |
Mike Cahill |
INF |
Sacred Heart University |
| 2005 |
Keith Moran |
P/INF |
Dean College |
| 2005 |
Bryan Colombero |
INF |
Dean College |
| 2005 |
Carlos Santini |
OF |
Dean College |
| 2004 |
Brian Cahill |
OF |
Western New England College |
| 2004 |
Ryan King |
P |
Siena College |
| 2003 |
David Andrew |
P |
Muhlenberg University |
| 2001 |
Jason Grover |
SS |
Rutgers University |
| 2001 |
Mike McCarthy |
OF |
Moravian College |
| 2001 |
Brad Loats |
P |
Richard Stockton College |
| 2001 |
Doug Rose |
OF |
Wentworth Institute of Technology |
| 2000 |
Pete Thilbault |
OF |
Vermont Technical College |
| 2000 |
Justin Kuruvilla |
C |
Drew University |
| 1999 |
Chris McLaughlin |
SS |
St. Joseph's University |
| 1999 |
Dave Daniels |
3B |
Mercer County Community College |
| 1998 |
Rob Birch |
1B |
Fairleigh Dickinson University, Madison |
| 1997 |
Wayne Horvath |
2B |
Raritan Valley Community College |
| 1996 |
Alex McKnight |
OF |
Bucknell University |
| 1996 |
Matt Thurlow |
1B |
Washington & Lee University |
| 1994 |
Chris Witwer |
OF |
University of Richmond |
| 1994 |
Mike Gallo |
P |
Raritan Valley Community College |
| 1992 |
John Rooney |
C |
C.W. Post College of Long Island University |
| 1992 |
Brett Slepokura |
SS |
University of Richmond |
