Past Champions
| Fall | ||||
| Season | Division | Grades | Champion | Finalist |
| 2014 | III | 7-10 | Chargers | Giants |
| 2014 | II | 5-6 | Chiefs | Bears |
| 2014 | I | 3-4 | Packers | Broncos |
| 2014 | Prep | K-2 | 49ers | Eagles |
| 2013 | III | 7-10 | Giants | Buccaneers |
| 2013 | II | 5-6 | Saints | Packers |
| 2013 | I | 3-4 | Lions | Redskins |
| 2013 | Prep | K-2 | Giants | Jets |
| 2012 | III | 7-8 | Saints | Bills |
| 2012 | II | 5-6 | Redskins | Rams |
| 2012 | I | 3-4 | Titans | Dolphins |
| 2012 | Prep | K-2 | Broncos | Browns |
| 2011 | III | 7-8 | Jaguars | Bears |
| 2011 | II | 5-6 | Lions | Panthers |
| 2011 | I | 3-4 | Dolphins | Patriots |
| 2011 | Prep | K-2 | Raiders | Seahawks |
| 2010 | III | 7-8 | Jets | Redskins |
| 2010 | II | 5-6 | Vikings | Packers |
| 2010 | I | 3-4 | Jaguars | Eagles |
| 2010 | Prep | K-2 | Chiefs | Chargers |
| 2009 | III | 7-8 | Falcons | Bills |
| 2009 | II | 5-6 | Ravens | Seahawks |
| 2009 | I | 3-4 | Vikings | Jaguars |
| 2009 | Prep | K-2 | Giants | Broncos |
| 2008 | III | 7-8 | Titans | Lions |
| 2008 | II | 5-6 | Eagles | Bears |
| 2008 | I | 3-4 | Saints | Patriots |
| 2007 | III | 7-8 | Falcons | Steelers |
| 2007 | II | 5-6 | Raiders | Jets |
| 2007 | I | 3-4 | Eagles | Dolphins |
| 2006 | II | 5-7 | Raiders | Patriots |
| 2006 | I | 3-4 | Buccaneers | Dolphins |
| 2005 | I | 3-8 | Falcons | Jets |
| Spring | ||||
| Season | Division | Grades | Champion | Finalist |
| 2014 | III | 7-10 | Raiders | Texans |
| 2014 | II | 5-6 | Bills | Giants |
| 2014 | I | 3-4 | Ravens | Saints |
| 2014 | Prep | K-2 | Raiders | Redskins |
| 2013 | III | 7-10 | Cardinals | Broncos |
| 2013 | II | 5-6 | Cardinals | Bengals |
| 2013 | I | 3-4 | Bengals | Cowboys |
| 2013 | Prep | K-2 | Cowboys | Chargers |
| 2012 | II | 5-6 | Bears | Texans |
| 2012 | I | 3-4 | Jets | Dolphins |
| 2012 | Prep | K-2 | Giants | Cowboys |
| 2011 | III | 7-8 | Chargers | Redskins |
| 2011 | II | 5-6 | Panthers | Lions |
| 2011 | I | 3-4 | Packers | Bills |
| 2011 | Prep | K-2 | Giants | Jaguars |
| 2010 | II | 5-6 | Bears | Vikings |
| 2010 | I | 3-4 | Falcons | Cowboys |
| 2010 | Prep | K-2 | Raiders | Rams |
| 2009 | III | 7-8 | Jets | Patriots |
| 2009 | II | 5-6 | Lions | Vikings |
| 2009 | I | 3-4 | Saints | Bears |
| 2009 | Prep | K-2 | Giants | Colts |
