| Years |
Contestants |
Winner |
| 2009 |
Matt Cahill, Riley Frost |
Riley Frost |
| 2010 |
Matt Cahill, Riley Frost, Eddie Wade |
Riley Frost |
| 2011 |
Tommy Barbait, Matt Cahill, Riley Frost |
Riley Frost |
| 2012 |
Matt Cahill, Matt Perron, Mike Polimeno |
Mike Polimeno |
| 2013 |
Matt Cahill, Riley Frost, David Miller, Matt Perron, Mike Polimeno |
Riley Frost |
| 2014 |
Tommy Barbati, Chris Blimberg, Chad Boschetti, Matt Cahill, Riley Frost, Mike Polimeno |
Mike Polimeno |
| 2015 |
Tommy Barbati, Chris Blimberg, Matt Cahill, Travis MacMurdo |
Chris Blimberg |
| 2016 |
Tommy Barbati, Matt Cahill, Travis MacMurdo, Mike Polimeno |
Tommy Barbati |
| 2017 |
Tommy Barbati, Maeve Cahill, Matt Cahill, Mike Polimeno |
Tommy Barbati |
| 2018 |
Matt Cahill, Riley Frost, Travis MacMurdo, David Miller |
Matt Cahill |
| 2019 |
Matt Cahill, Riley Frost, Cam Hodgson, Garrett Kingston |
Garrett Kingston |
| 2020 |
Matt Cahill, Dean Miller, Mike Polimeno, Sean Whelton |
Mike Polimeno |
| 2021 |
Matt Cahill, Matt Fronduto, Riley Frost, Derek Graffeo, Mike Polimeno, Sean Whelton |
Matt Fronduto |
| 2022 |
N/A |
N/A |
| 2023 |
N/A |
N/A |
